Put their testimony in a timeline. On the 911 tape she told dispatcher Doris Tramwell that she fought with the intruder but didnt specify a location. I invite your comments at any time and I'll try to monitor a little closer if anything sounds like a personal attack on someone else. Thought I'd never reach the end. The have financial problems but he increases the life policy. There was absolutely nothing to indicate anyone had gone into the garage and through the window; coming in or going out. Damon and moved some distance from where he was initially stabbed. A while ago I began to read "Dateline Purgatory: Examining the Case that Sentenced Darlie Routier to Death" by Kathy Cruz, and wasn't convinced by the points she made. Two additional stains were discovered on the left shoulder of the nightshirt shirt labeled LS1 and LS3. Satin is not responsible for killing those children. Regardless, I don't find a round trip of 150 yards would take much time at all for a 26 y/o woman with adrenaline pumping. Samford made clear that he had not changed his mind, and that he still believes Darlie is innocent. The problem these groups consistently run into is the evidence that convicted Darlie Routier. There was only one motion sensor in the back yard mounted about 6 feet up on a front corner post of the hot tub spa facing the rear of the house. Darlie has said more than once in post-conviction interviews from prison "How could I have done those things to myself? I do continue to maintain that Darin had some involvement. June 4th 2018 has a nice ring to it. LUBBOCK The husband of death row inmate Darlie Routier said Friday that he and his wife are divorcing to move on from the "limbo" they've been in since her arrest and conviction . Darlie Supporters just love to say that the blood droplets on the nightshirt aren't proof of anything because the shirt was stuffed in a paper bag (which it wasn't) with other items of clothing. Those of us on this site devoted to justice for two murdered little boys dont just smell bullshit a mile away we smell it across country. In other words, what the Darlie supporters are suggesting is that this was a well-orchestrated, well-coordinated conspiracy that included local, state, and federal law enforcement agencies, hospital employees, attorneys, paramedics, neighbors and co-workers all working together hand in hand to set up Darlie Routier. Some people have suggested that she may have originally decided to kill her children and herself but "chickened out" at the last minute from killing herself, or Darin woke up from the noise of her killing the boys and stopped her before she was able to kill herself. An intact expensive flower vase was found lying on the floor with long stem flowers. Darlie claimed the intruder dropped it on the floor and she picked it up. There is no evidence what so ever to support the theory of Darin drugging Darlie the night of the murders. Upon arrival he observed Darin Routier coming out of the front door wearing only pants with no shirt or shoes. While simultaneously ignoring strong evidence against the only adult in the room with BLOOD ALL OVER HER SHIRT AND FINGERPRINTS ALL OVER THE MURDER WEAPON!! She could have lost control of herself and in a blind fury stabbed Damon and Devon to death. Can you give us a ballpark figure of an outside time period there? I can't wait to tackle the newly posted one, JFK. James Cron found it odd that other than a blood smudge on the door leading to the utility room and two blood smudges on the side of the washing machine, there was nothing else past that point to indicate that an intruder had exited through the garage as Darlie had claimed; not one drop of blood anywhere. Plse don't bother answering as I prefer to look on the bright side of life. Tests revealed that it would stay on for 18 minutes after it was activated. She was laughing. This has yet to happen. This is mentioned here because some Darlie supporters use the 911 call in attempts to discredit the testimony of the first arriving Rowlette police officer, David Waddell. The fingerprint brush fibers did not contain any asbestos. 1)darlin stated that her child woke her up saying mommy, mommy. Shame on Viola Davis for choosing Darlie Routier to feature. It was one of the most brutal murders Ive ever been involved with, it stands out because of the brutality of those little boys who were murdered in such a cold-blooded fashion by their mother. It's part of an all-out push by the Innocence Project to . Each of the points that you raised were addressed in the article. At the crime scene investigators collected 3 damp towels from the utility room, 2 towels from the basket in the utility room, 4 washcloths from the top of the stairs, 3 towels from the backyard spa. Lol. This is a valuable resource you've complied. However, currently it seems it is trendy right now (for lack of a better term, my apologies) to sensationalize such tragedies with the label of wrongly convicted for ratings etc. If that is the case there would be a possibility that they are both innocent as far as killing the children and one of their weird. Shook told her they had been intercepted by her jailers. I find it laughable that people watch Dateline or some other t.v. Blood discovered on the inside of the cabinet doors where it had run down from the sink proved to be Darlies. When interviewed, she knows exactly how and when to cry and turn on the heart tugging emotions and people eat this up. Update 1/19: The Darlene Routier home has been temporarily taken off the market. She has also been charged with capital murder in the death of her six-year-old son, Devon, who was murdered at the same time as Damon. All the surgeon (Dr, Santos) did was take a peek at the cut, cleanse it, and close it right back up. These stains too were suggestive of cast-off. The shape and consistency of the blood drops found on the living room and kitchen floor indicated she was walking, not running at any time, as she claimed while supposedly chasing the intruder. Claims are frequently made such as botched evidence testing, contamination of the crime scene, manipulated evidence, prosecutorial misconduct, evidence suppression, witness tampering, jury tampering, perjury; you name it, it's been thrown out there. (Rule 157.49), DARLIE ROUTIER'S TESTIMONY AND THE INCRIMINATING LETTERS, Probably the biggest mistake made by Darlie Routier and her defense counsel during the trial was her insistence on testifying and her being allowed to. And more directly, why are you making general comments about the case RATHER THAN making a comment about the article? However, the test results on the nightshirt samples revealed more than Darlie Routier's attorney had bargained for. How would anyone know if Darlie cleaned up two footprints if she wiped them clean and all that's left for the luminol to show is a smear? In recent years some of the Darlie supporters have in fact convinced themselves that Darin Routier murdered his sons. Darin will have to tell you about him it's a long story, I know it's him. I saw him and I know it's him" The jailers intercepted the letters and gave them to the DA's office. SClemmons (author) from the Carolina Coast on June 29, 2018: Avery Dai Lyfe, I agree with you 100%. When I examined the scene after she told me this version of her story, I was unable to see the utility room floor from the vicinity of the light switch by looking across and over the kitchen island, because the island is too large, and I am taller than Darlie." What the Darlie supporters, including Darlie Kee cannot explain, is why Darlie constantly changed her accounts of what took place. Back to the 911 call, around 4 minutes into the call Darlie can be heard telling the first officer on the scene, David Waddell, Look out in the garage. That FBI guy is working on it. Yes, the DNA results have been sealed by the Courts and are now confidential. In this photo of Darlie smiling, just 8 days after the murders, you can see how quickly her neck wound is healing. (which she may have planned to do) And, if that were Darins intent, or motive, (insurance money) why didnt he kill her? Many people believe that an intruder broke into 26 year old Darlie's Rowlett, Texas home and murdered her young boys 5 year old Damon and 6 year old Devon in 1996, while gravely injuring Darlie. Darlie Routier was booked at the Rowlett City Jail and arraigned by Municipal Court Judge Owen Lokken. Did you hear him bark the night of the attack? Darlie paused, then calmly replied, Come to think of it, no, he didnt. (p.121). One group has second thoughts about the trial and the evidence and in conversation will express their opinion of doubt and provide specific reasons as to why they feel that way. SClemmons (author) from the Carolina Coast on October 12, 2018: Thank you Paula for your comments and your gracious insight. Interestingly, none of these "wet" towels were seen, recovered, or photographed when police and EMS arrived at the house 3 minutes after the 911 call. your pictures of big bruising on arm after she went home. Blood on the utility room door and washing machine identified as belonging to Darlie. Darlie had a laceration on the top of her right arm and she is right handed. They would work tirelessly to make sure she paid the price. Which Darlie, Darin, and her mother Darlie Kee, all violated. To say the least I have been so conflicted since originally delving into this case, I promised myself I would steer clear of any more news articles, TV shows, online information or books written on this topic. SClemmons (author) from the Carolina Coast on January 10, 2018: Wow Jade, that is news. Darlie will turn on the charm and the tears and use her "I'm the true victim here" little girl voice, convincing nearly each person that met with her that there was no way she could have murdered her sons. No blood found on the floor, only the outside of the door facing the kitchen and the washing machine on it's left side as you face it. Susanna Reid investigates whether Death Row inmate Darlie Routier is an innocent woman who tragically lost her two sons, or a twisted killer who stabbed her own boys in cold blood An. People that believe in Darlie Routier's innocence provide all kinds of reasons and theories that they often try to pass as fact as to how she couldn't have been the killer and/or how she deserves a retrial. I shouldn't have picked it up. I'm trying to get this to as many individuals that I'm aware have a strong interest in this case. It was found closed and in place when police investigators inspected it. They stated that she was a very materialistic person and was quite comfortable living in the upper middle class world and spending money. They bought an SUV, bought a Jaguar, bought a 30 foot cabin cruiser, installed a large somewhat gaudy fountain complete with running water and lights in their front yard, and had a $9,000 redwood spa built in the backyard. By the end of your article, you wrote that, in 2014, four retired crime scene experts reviewed all the evidence and concluded without a doubt that Darlie alone murdered Damon and Devon. Darlie claims she slept through everything. This would explain why none of her blood was on the sock and none of her blood was found anywhere along the route to where the sock was found. The federal court judge has not yet ruled on those DNA results. I also think there may have been a bit of a language barrier problem there. Darlie Routier, 48, has been on death row in Texas for more than 20 years Her sons Damon, five, and Devon, six, were stabbed to death on June 6, 1996 She was found guilty of Damon's murder but. Blood spatter found on the wall suggested that he had been stabbed a second time by someone who was bleeding. I don't even hear him anymore while I'm sleeping because I'm so used to hearing him bark. I think obviously if youre found guilty of murdering your children that the [death] penalty is a deserving sentence, and shes exactly where she should be, I think as soon as the federal appeal is over, the sentence will be upheld and the sentence will be carried out.. Then while in jail awaiting trial over the course of Nov. 1, 2, and 3, 1996, she wrote a series of letters to family and friends. When Darlie Routiers trial began on January 6, 1997, the prosecutors said that her main goal for staging a break-in, killing her sons, and slashing her own throat was to collect the money from her boys life insurance policies and deal with the familys financial difficulties. Numerous items from the crime scene were submitted. At the sentencing phase of the trial Darlie Routier was sentenced to death by lethal injection. There was one physician, Dr. Santos conducting the procedure accompanied by a resident (doctor in training) who was observing. Darlie supporters love to direct people to an old CBS 20/20 special taped 18 years ago in 1999, hosted by moderator Sylvia Chase. 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. I just read it for a second time. she changed her story to "finding" the knife lying on the floor. Anytime someone questions that or the evidence, people are quick to pounce. In order to rule out Darin Routier as a suspect, Pardo talked him into taking a polygraph examination. They are admitting two Project's lawyers to the appeal. Paramedic Jack Kolbye, the paramedic that tended to Damon in the house was called to testify. Murderer Theories Ranging from Darin Routier to a Rowlett Police Officer. Stephen Cooper's intent was to prove through DNA test results that an outside intruder was in fact in the house, committed the heinous murders of Darlie and Darin Routier's two sons, and attacked Darlie before fleeing the scene. I'm no psychologist either and it would be cool to hear some comments from someone that is. I'll have a good cry and fall asleep I hope.Peace, Paula. 11) her polygraph test. Square Feet: 2,740 sqft. Waddell instructed Darlie to get a towel and put pressure on the boy's wounds. SClemmons (author) from the Carolina Coast on February 04, 2020: Thanks for commenting again. Unfortunately, many if not most newcomers to the Darlie Routier case are immediately fed propaganda and manipulated facts of the case due to the large number of Darlie supporter blogs and websites. Although attempts had been made to clean the counter top and sink, tests with Luminol revealed blood on the top of the counter in front of the sink and on the floor. I have no doubts that he was accusing her in the 911 call based on what Darlie is saying to him, and I think that suggests a feeling of disgust and betrayal from his end. sometime after paramedic Koschak checked Devon and the time the police forensic team photographed the crime scene. With Darlie's emotions as they were after the boys were killed, I have trouble accepting Darlie's ability to think clearly enough to do much scene staging on her own. Paramedic Kolbye: She was standing next to Officer Waddell on the family room side of the bar, holding a towel to her neck. What are your thoughts on these theories SClemmons? darlie routier dna results 2021 darlie routier dna results 2021 (No Ratings Yet) . He ran down the stairs and into the room where the boys were. Douche. Darin and Darlie could have easily concocted a story to tell the police and rapidly staged the scene before she dialed 911. At the conclusion of the polygraph, and being under the auspices of attorney/client privilege and work product ethics, Parks would only say the examination was "inconclusive," but he didn't say she passed it either. The investigators and prosecution considered at one point the possibility that Darin may have ran the sock down to where it was found to make it look like it had been discarded by the intruder as he was running away. Despite what many Darlie supporters say and believe, she was not convicted by the silly string video. Greg Davis: Was there anything on Damons back, such as a towel, a rag, anything besides the clothes he was wearing? Darlie Routier Called 911 Saying An Intruder Attacked Her And Her Sons. What crap! Even you don't have an explanation for why darlie would go to death row just to cover up for her husband: an man who according to YOU just tried to kill her. She actually asked the judge if it was legal to do that which resulted in the courtroom spectators (including some jurors) breaking out in laughter. Due to most published literature referencing the Darlie Routier case being a one-sided opinion (the author either believes in her innocence or her guilt) the closest one can come to achieving unbiased information about the case and proceedings would result from reading the court transcripts in their entirety. After formal murder charges had been made and prior to Darlie's trial, her original court appointed attorneys, Doug Parks and Wayne Huff, obtained a sealed motion for a private polygraph examination of Darlie shortly before jury selection began. A friend of the family said that after the boy's funeral the immediate family and close friends all gathered at Darlie Kee's house. So, if money was the motive, they said, why did she leave Darin unharmed, who had an $800,000 insurance policy? Darin Routier, Darlie's husband was called to testify and also asked about the towels that Darlie stated she placed on Damon's back. They presented their conclusions to Mr. Samford and explained methodically how they came about them. Her two oldest boys are laying on the floor in their own blood stabbed to death and she never asked anyone about her baby upstairs? He was also courteous enough to put the knife back in the block when he came in. The transcripts also suggest that Darin Routier lied as well during his own testimony about the towels. I screamed out to my husband.". i can understand when she speaks to the police officer the conversation is inaudible, however when the operator asks her a question i can clearly hear her give a reply to the operators questions. The distance to where the sock was located from the Routier house is 75 yards, that's 450 feet round trip and can be completed walking a fast pace (Not running) in 5 minutes or less. ", Mercedes commented; "Right there where her boys were killed, and that's the first thing she said to me. The blood on the couch and pillow is what the Darlie supporters contend prove she was telling the truth about fighting an intruder. Norris testified that Darlie was a rude customer that came in every week, constantly cursed her children, and demanded that Darin buy her some jewelry. I really enjoy your articles as well. Why she would do such a thing, I don't know, I would have let him fry. She told the dispatcher "I was fighting" but in court she tried to say her words were "I was frightening," which obviously makes no sense at all. Cheers! 12)darins polygraph test 13) the 911 call. Anyone who's read anything about the Darlie Routier case knows that Routier was filmed spraying silly string on her son Devon's grave at a birthday celebration held for him. Even so, the prosecution was suspicious of Darin's role in the murders. I was there from the beginning to the end of that nightmare and although I believed her at first, it wasn't until the middle of the trial that I realized she did it. Darlie Routier: I put a towel on Damon's back. During the trial, the prosecution suggested that Darlie saw her two older boys as the source of her woes; she lost control of herself, and killed them as a means of putting an end to her personal problems, or as a way to spite Darin after several weeks of bickering about financial problems. Eileen Shirmer, a neighbor of Darlie's that took her child to Devons fifth birthday party, testified in court that Darlie became enraged over getting water on her from the kids playing with their squirt guns. Perhaps she just laid there on the couch stewing over the fight they had just had. She said it was then that she realized the boys had been attacked and savagely butchered. In doing this they neglect to provide all of the data or information about their position that might countermand what they've written. Upon the jury retiring for deliberation on February 1, 1997, 8 of the 12 jurors were immediately prepared to vote guilty, while the other 4 jurors weren't quite convinced. Police officers Wade and Ferrie testified in court that were posted at the front door and were ordered not to let anyone in the house during the investigation. I was convinced of her guilt as soon as I saw her injuries and actually listened over the years to her appeals. Obviously, if a retrial were somehow granted it still wouldn't change the forensic evidence that convicted her. The 1st round of DNA testing DID reveal *unknown* DNA from the crime scene. It was very traumatic, so after going through something so traumatic and watching my parents especially my mom I can't criticize Darlie much. Darlie Routier had no medical certification or training of any kind. Utter and complete NONSENSE!!!. Well apparently not the night of the murders. It wasn't bent in or out or stretched in any way to indicate someone had gone through it in either direction. from the tv show i was looking for you to speak about the written statement darlin made. When I first got him I thought I'd never sleep at night due to his constant barking. ", The Routier kitchen serrated knife used to cut the garage window screen. The website says "doctors" as if a whole team of surgeons were meticulously working on her in a race against the clock to save her life. Although it was difficult to find motive, I dare not question evil acts. Darlie Routier IS!!!!! We know she didn't ask about him (or check on him) from the time she called 911 to when she was admitted to the hospital, unless she asked the paramedics enroute to the hospital (which neither mentioned in court) or Darin told her Drake was fine before she dialed 911; again, not mentioned anywhere. One such author and this author have discussed the case on her HubPage on several occasions and we both politely agreed to disagree. She absolutely knows what she did, yet can be interviewed numerous times and yet seem convincingly wronged. Hopefully 2021 will be a better year for all! Though not admissible in court, the judge ordered the Dallas County jail to allow the polygraph test without the knowledge of the district attorneys office. And disgust by your carefree accusations of strangers killing children without reasonable evidence. A Dallas County judge has admitted two lawyers from the national office of the Innocence Project to the case. Cron quietly approached Lt Jack outside in front of the house and told him that from what he was seeing so far, it was starting to look like these murders had been committed by someone living in the house. Most members of this second group get the most hateful when challenged to provide a credible source to backup a statement they've made that they're trying to pass as fact. When you put information together, read articles, watch Youtube, pick a part information. During the trial, Dr. Alejandro Santos, the trauma surgeon that closed Darlie's wounds was called to testify. Just a wild guess might be because Darlie failed it. Is she a vain narcissist yes I think so. Interestingly, of the cuts Darlie had on her, the two areas she was most proud of, her face and her breasts, were uninjured. Darlie and her mother claim they watched it 9 times. *The most commonly abused date rape drugs, or "club drugs," are Rohypnol, also called "roofies"; gamma hydroxybutyric acid, also called "liquid ecstasy"; ketamine, also called "Special K," and tablet form ecstasy, also called "Molly," which is often crushed and mixed into a drink. IF the world runs on that oxymoron theory, 99% the criminals should never be tried at all, because 99% crime were committed WITHOUT any witness! (Did they have Photoshop back then?) It was there that Darlie announced to everyone that she and Darin already had plans in place to take a trip to Europe together, get some plastic surgery done to remove the scar from her neck, and hopefully conceive another child while on the trip, preferably a daughter. Darlie Kee and Darin appeared in the June, 2018 ABC documentary: The Last Defense. None of the forensic evidence was matching Darlie's initial story. This was confirmed by Darlie's attorney, Stephan Cooper. There was blood all over the carpet around the boys and all over the kitchen floor. There have been numerous documentaries, a made for TV movie, countless websites and blogs, and several books written about the case. The spa had a hot tub, a TV, a bar, and a stereo system in it. A relative that was with Darlie from her initial hospital stay though the funeral stated that the hardest she ever saw Darlie cry was the day she was arrested. This suggests that the towel either got moved accidentally by investigators (which is highly unlikely) or it got placed there by someone (possibly Darin?) SClemmons (author) from the Carolina Coast on July 05, 2018: fedematias, the link worked fine when I tried it just now. 8) never knew about dog til your blog. There is no way she could have committed suicide. Darlie supporters love to say a "nick" or flattened area in the chain "proves" that it saved her life because it kept the knife blade from lacerating her carotid artery; pure speculation. When Im in the courtroom I am bound by certain things. Darlie Routier told a detailed story about a man that broke into her home and stabbed her sons to death. Probably the best one out there. He further said, "Every time someone contacts Darlie's family claiming they have the evidence that will free her, I have to stop what I'm doing, listen to them, and calm them down.". If they choose to kill me, thats my innocent blood that will be on their hands.. She never said she carried into the living room where it had obviously been laid down next to Damon's body. Well researched, well done. Author Note - Out of due respect for the victims and family, no photos of the boy's body's will be displayed here. You make the claim (you're really only repeating the psychobabble of David Nabors) that Darlie cleaned up two footprints. If the defense was allowed the proper time to prepare, THERE WOULD HAVE BEEN A DIFFERENT OUT COME. July 1, 2011. Hi yall! I'll have to find the exact date of that interview for you. WHY? No cuts were found under either one of her arms. I believe the immediate emotion and shock would've been too much to overcome in such a short time to start covering for her at that point (even five minutes would be too soon). Could you point me to your source for that? SClemmons (author) from the Carolina Coast on February 20, 2018: Du bist genau richtig. I have noticed that in some murders of children, the mother was on medication for depression. Hi Folks.I must confess, It took me L O N G time & volumes of reading and even more soul-searching to finally arrive at accepting that Darlie is guilty. In turn, Mize was upset with Darlie and supposedly called her and according to Darlie, he threatened her. Darlie has always maintained her innocence. Ive sat through most of the documentaries and heard her mother get caught in lie after lie and watched Darlie constantly play the victim card and it actually sickened me. Darlie Routier was a 26-year-old mother of three boys at the time of the killings. This is a highly debated case and it's important for the reader to understand that these debates are not about someone awaiting trial, Darlie Routier has already had her day in court. The stems were unbroken giving the investigators the impression that they had just been laid there, not knocked over during a struggle. Posted on May 15, 2022. Darlie Routier is on death row, convicted of murdering her two sons. SClemmons (author) from the Carolina Coast on April 06, 2018: I apologize for that happening and that you feel that way. While watching the Last Defense last night, I thought to myself-is any of this true? Although a private memorial service had taken place minutes earlier, images of Darlie smiling and laughing and spraying silly string on Devon's grave on his 7th birthday didn't sit well with observers. And, they never offer any reasons as to why all of these different people would want to do that and perjure themselves.
Philip Incarnati Net Worth,
Philippe Cousteau Plane Crash,
Articles D